So what would be 'maximising the common good' in this situation?
I believe the members who have been trying to get the personal info removed are working to maximise the common good. Whether or not it has been a simple statement of wishing personal information to be removed, or more directly, by starting polls and threads to discuss how to go about it and try and find some consensus.
Working to resolve the sock puppet issue would also maximise the common good, imo.
Members that contstantly disrupt threads and use character assassination tactics to bully others from what they are trying to resolve, are not working towards the common good...imo.
I think intention is everything and I'm wondering, Chico, if you intend for this experiment to fail?
Lee